{ "schema_version": "1.0", "signal_id": "volume-spike-without-price-move", "slug": "volume-spike-without-price-move", "family": "volume", "registry_version": 1, "registered_on": "2026-09-05", "computed_at": "2026-09-05T09:40:52Z", "code_commit": "283c309", "data_as_of": "2026-08-06", "universe_as_of": "point-in-time", "sample_grade": "STRONG", "headline_horizon": 5, "title": "Volume spike without price move", "plain_english": "Volume was at least three times the stock's own twenty-day average while the closing price barely moved \u2014 under 1% either way.", "definition": "volume[t] >= 3.0 * avg(volume, 20)[t]\nAND abs(close[t] / close[t-1] - 1) <= 0.01", "headline_parameters": { "volume_multiple": 3.0, "move_cap": 0.01 }, "sample": { "n_raw": 9438, "n_eff": 9111.0, "deff": 1.036, "rho": 0.0175, "m_bar": 3.05, "n_eff_raw_design": 7531.3, "rho_raw_design": 0.1234, "deff_raw_design": 1.253, "distinct_stocks": 1502, "distinct_dates": 3092, "date_range": [ "2011-10-05", "2026-08-05" ], "censoring_rate": 0.00509, "max_quarter_share": 0.0353, "max_stock_share": 0.0063, "max_sector_share": null, "control_rung_distribution": { "0": 0.7455, "1": 0.2271, "2": 0.0272, "3": 0.0002, "4": 0.0 }, "mean_controls_per_event": 19.03 }, "horizons": [ { "days": 1, "n_eff": 9076.5, "hit_rate": 0.4251, "control_hit_rate": 0.4244, "lift": 0.0007, "lift_ci95": [ -0.0103, 0.0116 ], "lift_ci_method": "cluster_bootstrap_date_block_B10000_BCa", "lift_p_value": 0.9198, "median_change": -0.00297, "control_median_change": -0.00266, "excess_median": -0.0003, "trimmed_mean_change": -0.00224, "spread": { "p10": -0.0303, "p25": -0.016, "p75": 0.0093, "p90": 0.0269 }, "mfe": 0.0128, "mae": -0.0152, "break_even_hit_rate": 0.5556, "break_even_assumptions": { "bracket": 0.02, "round_trip_cost": 0.002225, "impact": 0.0 }, "benchmark_median_change": 0.0, "interval_includes_zero": true, "interval_check": { "bootstrap_half_width": 0.01098, "analytic_clustered_half_width": 0.01006, "wilson_on_n_eff_half_width": 0.01017, "ratio_bootstrap_to_analytic": 1.091, "ratio_bootstrap_to_wilson_on_rate": 1.079 }, "n_eff_raw_design": 8166.5 }, { "days": 3, "n_eff": 9193.1, "hit_rate": 0.4618, "control_hit_rate": 0.4614, "lift": 0.0003, "lift_ci95": [ -0.0105, 0.0113 ], "lift_ci_method": "cluster_bootstrap_date_block_B10000_BCa", "lift_p_value": 0.9618, "median_change": -0.00269, "control_median_change": -0.00231, "excess_median": -0.00038, "trimmed_mean_change": -0.00131, "spread": { "p10": -0.0506, "p25": -0.0256, "p75": 0.0196, "p90": 0.0499 }, "mfe": 0.0228, "mae": -0.0244, "break_even_hit_rate": 0.5556, "break_even_assumptions": { "bracket": 0.02, "round_trip_cost": 0.002225, "impact": 0.0 }, "benchmark_median_change": -0.0014, "interval_includes_zero": true, "interval_check": { "bootstrap_half_width": 0.0109, "analytic_clustered_half_width": 0.00988, "wilson_on_n_eff_half_width": 0.01019, "ratio_bootstrap_to_analytic": 1.103, "ratio_bootstrap_to_wilson_on_rate": 1.07 }, "n_eff_raw_design": 7657.8 }, { "days": 5, "n_eff": 9111.0, "hit_rate": 0.4571, "control_hit_rate": 0.4703, "lift": -0.0132, "lift_ci95": [ -0.0231, -0.0032 ], "lift_ci_method": "cluster_bootstrap_date_block_B10000_BCa", "lift_p_value": 0.009, "median_change": -0.00399, "control_median_change": -0.00221, "excess_median": -0.00177, "trimmed_mean_change": -0.00103, "spread": { "p10": -0.0647, "p25": -0.0321, "p75": 0.0267, "p90": 0.0657 }, "mfe": 0.0296, "mae": -0.031, "break_even_hit_rate": 0.5556, "break_even_assumptions": { "bracket": 0.02, "round_trip_cost": 0.002225, "impact": 0.0 }, "benchmark_median_change": -0.00369, "interval_includes_zero": false, "interval_check": { "bootstrap_half_width": 0.00995, "analytic_clustered_half_width": 0.00984, "wilson_on_n_eff_half_width": 0.01023, "ratio_bootstrap_to_analytic": 1.012, "ratio_bootstrap_to_wilson_on_rate": 0.973 }, "n_eff_raw_design": 7531.3, "distribution": { "bin_lo": -0.13134, "bin_hi": 0.17225, "bin_width": 0.012144, "event_share": [ 0.00545, 0.0097, 0.01101, 0.01831, 0.02649, 0.03575, 0.05232, 0.0678, 0.09058, 0.11195, 0.1356, 0.10737, 0.08175, 0.06322, 0.04981, 0.03575, 0.02703, 0.0194, 0.01472, 0.01101, 0.00709, 0.00567, 0.0048, 0.00327, 0.00414 ], "control_share": [ 0.00433, 0.0064, 0.00986, 0.01487, 0.02303, 0.03457, 0.05086, 0.07045, 0.09538, 0.11643, 0.12791, 0.112, 0.0872, 0.06733, 0.04928, 0.03588, 0.0264, 0.01967, 0.01412, 0.01032, 0.00818, 0.00574, 0.00419, 0.00296, 0.00264 ] } }, { "days": 10, "n_eff": 9198.8, "hit_rate": 0.4844, "control_hit_rate": 0.4844, "lift": -0.0, "lift_ci95": [ -0.0112, 0.011 ], "lift_ci_method": "cluster_bootstrap_date_block_B10000_BCa", "lift_p_value": 0.9968, "median_change": -0.00169, "control_median_change": -0.00152, "excess_median": -0.00017, "trimmed_mean_change": 0.00189, "spread": { "p10": -0.0848, "p25": -0.0423, "p75": 0.0417, "p90": 0.0967 }, "mfe": 0.0435, "mae": -0.0431, "break_even_hit_rate": 0.5556, "break_even_assumptions": { "bracket": 0.02, "round_trip_cost": 0.002225, "impact": 0.0 }, "benchmark_median_change": -0.00956, "interval_includes_zero": true, "interval_check": { "bootstrap_half_width": 0.0111, "analytic_clustered_half_width": 0.00967, "wilson_on_n_eff_half_width": 0.01021, "ratio_bootstrap_to_analytic": 1.147, "ratio_bootstrap_to_wilson_on_rate": 1.087 }, "n_eff_raw_design": 7215.5 }, { "days": 20, "n_eff": 9009.7, "hit_rate": 0.5073, "control_hit_rate": 0.5064, "lift": 0.0009, "lift_ci95": [ -0.0109, 0.0133 ], "lift_ci_method": "cluster_bootstrap_date_block_B10000_BCa", "lift_p_value": 0.8834, "median_change": 0.00163, "control_median_change": 0.00311, "excess_median": -0.00148, "trimmed_mean_change": 0.00932, "spread": { "p10": -0.1126, "p25": -0.0558, "p75": 0.0667, "p90": 0.1417 }, "mfe": 0.0665, "mae": -0.0593, "break_even_hit_rate": 0.5556, "break_even_assumptions": { "bracket": 0.02, "round_trip_cost": 0.002225, "impact": 0.0 }, "benchmark_median_change": -0.0225, "interval_includes_zero": true, "interval_check": { "bootstrap_half_width": 0.01214, "analytic_clustered_half_width": 0.00966, "wilson_on_n_eff_half_width": 0.01032, "ratio_bootstrap_to_analytic": 1.256, "ratio_bootstrap_to_wilson_on_rate": 1.176 }, "n_eff_raw_design": 7022.0 } ], "gates": [ { "id": "n_eff", "label": "Effective sample size", "threshold": ">= 100", "observed": "9111", "passed": true }, { "id": "distinct_dates", "label": "Distinct event dates", "threshold": ">= 60", "observed": "3092", "passed": true }, { "id": "distinct_stocks", "label": "Distinct securities", "threshold": ">= 25", "observed": "1502", "passed": true }, { "id": "calendar_span", "label": "Calendar span", "threshold": ">= 5 years", "observed": "14.8 years", "passed": true }, { "id": "quarter_share", "label": "Largest share in one quarter", "threshold": "<= 20.0%", "observed": "3.5%", "passed": true }, { "id": "stock_share", "label": "Largest share from one security", "threshold": "<= 5.0%", "observed": "0.6%", "passed": true }, { "id": "censoring", "label": "Censoring rate", "threshold": "<= 2.0%", "observed": "0.5%", "passed": true }, { "id": "control_match", "label": "Events on relaxation rung 3-4", "threshold": "<= 20.0%", "observed": "0.0%", "passed": true } ], "multiple_testing": { "variants_in_grid": 25, "tests_on_site": 1125, "bh_fdr_q": 0.1, "passes_fdr": true, "adjusted_p": 0.010125, "raw_p": 0.009 }, "years": [ { "year": 2011, "n_eff": 73.9, "lift": -0.0144 }, { "year": 2012, "n_eff": 293.2, "lift": 0.012 }, { "year": 2013, "n_eff": 298.5, "lift": -0.0172 }, { "year": 2014, "n_eff": 332.4, "lift": -0.0202 }, { "year": 2015, "n_eff": 389.0, "lift": -0.0624 }, { "year": 2016, "n_eff": 434.3, "lift": -0.0293 }, { "year": 2017, "n_eff": 638.4, "lift": -0.0054 }, { "year": 2018, "n_eff": 625.2, "lift": 0.007 }, { "year": 2019, "n_eff": 504.3, "lift": -0.0009 }, { "year": 2020, "n_eff": 475.2, "lift": -0.0196 }, { "year": 2021, "n_eff": 654.6, "lift": -0.0303 }, { "year": 2022, "n_eff": 755.5, "lift": -0.0143 }, { "year": 2023, "n_eff": 950.2, "lift": 0.0195 }, { "year": 2024, "n_eff": 952.3, "lift": -0.0166 }, { "year": 2025, "n_eff": 1043.1, "lift": -0.0085 }, { "year": 2026, "n_eff": 642.7, "lift": -0.0436 } ], "regimes": [ { "trend": "above", "vol_tercile": 1, "n_eff": 31.0, "lift": -0.0201 }, { "trend": "above", "vol_tercile": 2, "n_eff": 32.6, "lift": -0.1269 }, { "trend": "above", "vol_tercile": 3, "n_eff": 142.0, "lift": -0.0184 }, { "trend": "below", "vol_tercile": 1, "n_eff": 3193.6, "lift": 0.0035 }, { "trend": "below", "vol_tercile": 2, "n_eff": 2961.8, "lift": -0.0127 }, { "trend": "below", "vol_tercile": 3, "n_eff": 2746.8, "lift": -0.0316 } ], "robustness": { "split_half_same_sign": true, "split_half": { "first": -0.0172, "second": -0.0092 }, "years_positive": 13, "years_total": 16, "non_overlapping_lift": -0.0147, "sector_matched_lift": null, "cost_adjusted_lift": -0.0124, "censoring_worst_case_lift": -0.0155, "parameter_grid_median_lift": -0.0103, "knife_edge": false, "parameter_grid": { "axis_a": "volume_multiple", "axis_b": "move_cap", "cells": [ { "a": 2.0, "b": 0.005, "lift": -0.0052, "n_eff": 15666.0 }, { "a": 2.0, "b": 0.0075, "lift": -0.0095, "n_eff": 23051.0 }, { "a": 2.0, "b": 0.01, "lift": -0.0115, "n_eff": 30252.0 }, { "a": 2.0, "b": 0.0125, "lift": -0.0103, "n_eff": 37269.0 }, { "a": 2.0, "b": 0.015, "lift": -0.0118, "n_eff": 44122.0 }, { "a": 2.5, "b": 0.005, "lift": -0.0093, "n_eff": 8297.0 }, { "a": 2.5, "b": 0.0075, "lift": -0.0136, "n_eff": 12163.0 }, { "a": 2.5, "b": 0.01, "lift": -0.015, "n_eff": 15959.0 }, { "a": 2.5, "b": 0.0125, "lift": -0.0136, "n_eff": 19729.0 }, { "a": 2.5, "b": 0.015, "lift": -0.0161, "n_eff": 23333.0 }, { "a": 3.0, "b": 0.005, "lift": -0.0039, "n_eff": 4944.0 }, { "a": 3.0, "b": 0.0075, "lift": -0.0096, "n_eff": 7207.0 }, { "a": 3.0, "b": 0.01, "lift": -0.0132, "n_eff": 9438.0 }, { "a": 3.0, "b": 0.0125, "lift": -0.0128, "n_eff": 11582.0 }, { "a": 3.0, "b": 0.015, "lift": -0.0145, "n_eff": 13686.0 }, { "a": 3.5, "b": 0.005, "lift": -0.004, "n_eff": 3124.0 }, { "a": 3.5, "b": 0.0075, "lift": -0.0064, "n_eff": 4509.0 }, { "a": 3.5, "b": 0.01, "lift": -0.0126, "n_eff": 5896.0 }, { "a": 3.5, "b": 0.0125, "lift": -0.0105, "n_eff": 7254.0 }, { "a": 3.5, "b": 0.015, "lift": -0.0138, "n_eff": 8562.0 }, { "a": 4.0, "b": 0.005, "lift": -0.0038, "n_eff": 2132.0 }, { "a": 4.0, "b": 0.0075, "lift": -0.0026, "n_eff": 3048.0 }, { "a": 4.0, "b": 0.01, "lift": -0.007, "n_eff": 3989.0 }, { "a": 4.0, "b": 0.0125, "lift": -0.0056, "n_eff": 4882.0 }, { "a": 4.0, "b": 0.015, "lift": -0.0077, "n_eff": 5740.0 } ] }, "entry_delayed_lift": -0.0126, "placebo_lift": 0.0026 }, "control_seed": 42, "control_stats": { "events": 9473, "events_with_controls": 9473, "unmatched": 0, "mean_controls_per_event": 19.04 }, "cost_assumption_source": { "generated_at": "2026-09-05T04:19:20Z", "cash_equity_rate_version": "2026-09-05" }, "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/", "method_url": "https://learnnifty.com/base-rates/methodology/", "disclaimer": "Historical frequencies only. Not investment advice, a recommendation or a price target. LearnNifty is not registered with SEBI as an Investment Adviser or Research Analyst." }